Dinner Menu


Fried Brussels

crispy brussels drizzled with sweet shoyu and dukka spice 9

Fried Cheese Curd

fresh local cheese curd served with a chipotle berry sauce 12

Loaded Potato Skins

loaded with cheddar cheese, bacon and scallions and a side of sour cream 11

Crab Cakes

2 jumbo crab cakes served with house Cajun remoulade sauce 14

Bay Fries

tossed in Old Bay seasoning and served with a Cajun Aoili 10

Mac N Cheese Trio

your choice of 3 sampler mac n cheeses; regular, buffalo, BBQ bacon or jalapeno popper 12

Chicken Wings

10- choice of hot, medium, mild, BBQ, sweet heat BBQ, Jack Daniels, Nashville hot, sweet chili, garlic parmesan. Served with homemade blue cheese 15

Onion Rings

one-pound beer battered onion rings served with a side of homemade petal sauce 9

Bacon Wrapped Jalapenos

stuffed with a cream cheese and cheddar cheese and baked to perfection. Served with a chipotle raspberry sauce 15

Chicken Fingers

4-honey mustard, BBQ, sweet heat BBQ, ranch, mild, medium, hot, garlic parmesan 11


brown gravy and fresh local cheese curd 15 whole
8 half

Prime Rib Poutine

shaved prime rib, brown gravy and fresh local cheese curd 18 whole
11 half


Chicken Tenders

2 chicken tenders with fries 9

Hot Dog

hoffman hot dog with fries 8

Pasta with Marinara

pasta with marinara 8

Mac N Cheese

bowl of homemade mac n cheese 7


FLAG POLE Fish N Chips

beer battered & served on a kaiser with lettuce, tomato & onion, tartar and coleslaw 16


3 of our famous fish tacos served with a heaping portion of fried fish and topped with homemade mango-jalapeno salsa, a dollop of coleslaw, and drizzled with a homemade lime crema 16

POTTER Shrimp Tacos

3 tortillas with melted cheddar and stuffed with blackened grilled shrimp and mixed with a crunchy sweet coleslaw and homemade lime crema drizzled on top 16

ROUND Reuben

grilled corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, thousand island dressing on toasted rye bread 14


thinly sliced prime rib puled high on a toasted baguette with melted povolone and served with au jus 19

DEVILS OVEN Spicy Chicken Sandwich

house spicy crispy chicken sandwich topped with a sweet coleslaw and dill pickle chip 15

BLACK & Bleu Burger

eight-ounce burger topped with bleu cheese crumbles, bacon, and sauteed onions 16

The BIG Burger

eight-ounce burger topped with melted American cheese, Thousand Islands dressing, pickles, lettuce, tomato and bacon 16

Not Your MACDONALD Burger

eight-ounce burger topped with melted cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, jalapenos, and onion rings drizzled with sweet heat BBQ 16

The GRENELL Surf and Turf Burger

eight-ounce burger topped with melted cheddar cheese, seasoned shrimp, lettuce, tomato, and a lime crema 18


1864 HOUSE

crisp romaine, carrots, cucumbers, red onion, craisins, and pecans with our house maple balsamic 13 Add chicken $4


romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan and croutons 10 Add Chicken $4.00

BELLE Mediterranean

salami, pepperoni, kalamata olives, tomatoes, red onion, provolone cheese, pepperoncini on a bed of romaine lettuce, served with our Greek Vinaigrette dressing 14


Bacon Corn Chowder


FAIRYLAND French Onion



Chicken Riggies

sautéed chicken breast, onion, cherry and bell peppers, basil with rigatoni in a spicy tomato vodka cream sauce and topped with parmesan 22

Chicken Parmesan

chicken breast is hand breaded, fried and finished with our marinara and melted buffalo mozzarella accompanied with a side of angel hair pasta and marinara 22

Pasta Primavera

broccoli, tri-color peppers, and zucchini with a creamy garlic Parmesan cheese sauce 16 Add Chicken- $

Crispy Pan Fried Duck

pan fried duck cooked to your liking and served with mashed potatoes or baked and vegetable 25


NY Strip

twelve-ounce NY Strip rubbed with a house blend of eight spices and served with mashed potatoes or baked potato and vegetable 43

Filet Mignon

hand trimmed nine-ounce filet topped with a garlic and herb compound butter and served with mashed potatoes or baked potato and vegetable 41

Jack Daniels Sirloin Tips

sirloin tips marinated in a house Jack Daniels sauces and served over a bed of mashed potatoes and grilled vegetable 24


SPORT ISLAND Shrimp Newburgh

shrimp in a Newburgh cheese sauce and baked with a crispy bread topping 21


bacon BBQ mac n cheese with fried onion straws 14

BIG GUILT Buffalo Chicken Mac N Cheese

chunks of chicken breast in a buffalo style mac n cheese 14

SUNSET Jalapeno Popper

sauteed jalapenos and bacon and drizzled with a chipotle raspberry sauce 15

LAZY B. Homemade Mac

extra creamy and cheesy and baked to perfection 10